Pudding is to Christmas what Turkey is to Thanksgiving! These non-boring pudding recipes are sure to make your Christmas a very memorable one!
Featured image from SweetestMenu
1. Pumpkin Bread Pudding
This cozy bread pudding is full of fall spices and flaky, buttery croissants.
If you aren’t having the traditional pudding, then you need to try this Instant Pot Alternative Christmas Pudding. It’s chocolate, through and through!
3. Christmas Ice Cream Pudding Bombe
Looking for an easy make-ahead Christmas dessert? Try my Amazing Ice Cream Pudding Bombe filled with pistachios, cranberries and Turkish delight and drizzled with chocolate.
4. Sticky Toffee Pudding
This traditional British Sticky Toffee Pudding dessert gets a slight makeover with sweet California prunes instead of dates. Tender sponge cake is coated in a buttery and luscious caramel sauce. Every bite is to die for!
5. Eggnog Cranberry Pudding
Special Breakfast Christmas! Christmas Eggnog Cranberry Bread Pudding with Vanilla Rum Sauce is fabulous! You’re going to love the bursting flavor of the tartness of the freshly, baked cranberries intertwined in the creamy, eggnog custard bread pudding.
6. Eggnog Bread Pudding With Warm Whiskey Sauce
It’s just not the holidays without eggnog, and there’s no better way to consume it than in a big slice of Eggnog Bread Pudding with Warm Whiskey Sauce!
7. Paleo and Gluten-Free Sticky Date Pudding
If you’re looking for a little something to stand tall front and center in your Christmas dessert spread, look no further. This healthy, grain-free, naturally sweetened sticky date pudding is dressed to impress… and don’t forget the tinsel!
8. Easy-To-Make Homemade Chocolate Pudding
You have to try this homemade chocolate pudding recipe. When you have a big family, it is much cheaper to just make it at home and it makes for a delicious after-school snack or an easy dessert.
9. Mint Chocolate Pudding Pie
This creamy, minty, chocolatey pie offers everything you’d expect from a Christmas pudding pie. Silky smooth, easy to make and bursting with flavors that everyone loves!
10. Chocolate Chip Cookie Layered Pudding
Layers of chocolate chip cookies, cream cheese, chocolate pudding, and Cool Whip. Perfect almost no-bake dessert for holidays and get-togethers.
11. Gingerbread Pudding Cake
Easy homemade pudding cake! This Gingerbread Pudding Cake is a moist apple gingerbread cake that makes its own caramel apple sauce while it bakes.
12. Foolproof Yorkshire Pudding
13. Hungarian Poppy Seed Bread Pudding
This bread pudding is a Christmas classic in Hungary. Poppy seed is a favorite ingredient all over Central Europe and is a symbol of wealth and fertility. It is quick and easy to make with a simple recipe!
14. Blueberry Pudding Cake
Grab a spoon and dig into this Blueberry Pudding Cake – a luscious, warm blueberry sauce is hidden under a perfectly sweet lemon-almond cake.
15. Easy Pumpkin Bread Pudding
Served warm with some vanilla ice cream, a good pumpkin bread pudding can become your favorite very quickly. It is easy to make and can be done with your kids!
16. Muffin Tin Bread Pudding
Try out this easy Muffin Tin Bread Pudding. They are perfect for holiday parties because they come out in individual servings and since each one is cooked in its own little compartment you can make multiple flavors so everyone gets something they like!
17. Christmas Pudding With Apricot, Fig and Orange
This pudding is a gloriously rich, dark and stodgy in the nicest possible way a pudding can be, but the figs give it an almost honey-like sweetness and apricots and oranges bring a tang and some tartness to the party!
18. Steamed Molasses Raisin Pudding
Steamed Molasses Raisin Pudding. A longtime Newfoundland favorite that’s easy to make and is delicious served with our recipe for the simple butterscotch sauce.
19. Vegan Sticky Toffee Gingerbread Pudding
20. Eggnog Pudding
Eggnog Pudding, a homemade pudding made with eggnog is yummy on its own or in desserts!
21. Low Carb Christmas Pudding
Enjoy this low carb Christmas pudding as the crowning glory of your festive meal. It’s sugar-free, gluten-free and suitable for diabetics. Even better, it’s ready in just over 10 minutes!
22. Slow Cooker Gingerbread Pudding Cake
An easy make-ahead dessert perfect for the holidays! This spiced Gingerbread Pudding Cake cooks in the slow cooker and keeps your oven free.
23. Chocolate Cherry Christmas Pudding Bliss Balls
If you don’t like Christmas pudding, these are named Chocolate Cherry Christmas Pudding Bliss Balls because they kinda look like a Christmas Pudding, rather than tasting like one!
24. Gran’s Chocolate Chrismas Pudding
There’s something really special about following a recipe that has been passed down from mother to daughter for generations. This recipe is chock full of tradition and absolutely delicious!
25. Chocolate Christmas Pudding With White Chocolate Custard
If you need an antidote to the traditional Christmas Pudding, give this recipe a try!
26. Crockpot Christmas Pudding
The fudge itself really easy to make, just four ingredients. The decorating is a little more tricky but nothing too taxing. It makes a fabulous homemade Christmas gift that will be loved!
27. Christmas Plum Pudding
Plum pudding has a dark history. It used to be illegal to eat because it was banned for a time as a pagan decadence in Oliver Cromwell’s England. This Plum Pudding, adapted from Eliza Acton’s 1845 cookbook, is a heavy, hearty dessert that stays true to its time period.
28. Nourishing Instant Pot Christmas Pudding
Starring traditional Christmas flavors, this simple but nourishing Christmas pudding is also free of gluten and refined sugar. It even uses coconut oil instead of suet.
29. Slow Cooker Cranberry and Vanilla Steamed Pudding
This recipe for a slow cooker cranberry and vanilla steamed pudding would be great as an alternative to Christmas pudding or just as a winter dessert.
30. Christmas Pudding With Hard Sauce
Our recipe for Christmas Pudding with Hard Sauce is a quicker, easier version of the classic British dessert, but with all of the spicy delicious flavor!
31. Half Syn Chocolate Christmas Pudding Cakes
It’s nearly Christmas, and what could be better than a mouthful of Chocolate Christmas Pudding?! These Half Syn Chocolate Christmas Pudding Cakes won’t break your syn allowance either – just half a syn each!
32. Classic Paleo Christmas Pudding
This incredible paleo Christmas pudding is full of festive flavors, yet it’s a much healthier than a traditional version. It’s made with a secret ingredient to keep it luscious and moist.
33. Christmas Figgy Pudding
The name itself conjures visions of Christmas and sugarplums and family… and tradition. A moist and tender Christmas pudding, redolent with the spices of Christmas, figs, and oranges.
34. Christmas Pudding Cupcakes
These Christmas Pudding Cupcakes are the Christmas baking project for the person who is just not a baker!
35. Christmas Pudding Malteser Cake
If you’re a fan of maltesers and love Christmas puddings, why not combine the two?
36. Oreo Christmas Puddings
These little Oreo cookie Christmas Puddings are super easy to make. They’d make the most perfect little Night Before Christmas cookies for Santa, or as sweet snacks between opening gifts on Christmas morning.
37. Traditional British Christmas Pudding
This remarkably easy, rich, sticky and spicy-but-not-overpowering pudding has a hint of chocolate. It’s love at first taste!
38. Vegan Christmas Pudding
The Ultimate Vegan Christmas Pudding. It’s dark, rich, fruity, moist & boozy & so much lighter than the dense, heavy puddings you might have tried in the past!
39. Christmas Pudding Protein Balls
Aren’t they so cute! They would make a lovely gift – you could wrap them individually or put several in a little box and tie it with a ribbon!
40. Christmas Pudding Bites
These mini Christmas puddings that taste JUST like the real thing but are made from nothing but raw, healthy and natural ingredients. Yep, right down to the decorations on top!